I agree
with what Aimee Bender had to say: as long as the work is interesting, I really
don’t care. Even though they are listed as non-fiction, they’re still books.
They still have to engage the reader and make them want to keep reading, and to
do so they need an interesting plot. If maybe ninety percent of the novel is
true, then who cares if the other ten percent is just to make things
interesting? The author is doing us a favor, really. They’re adding that ten
percent into the plot line because that means there wasn’t enough action to
keep us interested the whole way through the story they had to tell.
Now, I
do mind if only half of the novel is true. Then it shouldn’t be labeled as
non-fiction writing. When you’re only getting half of the story, but you are
lead to believe that it’s the whole story, then that’s a bit deceiving and I’d
feel like I was being lied to or cheated. If half of the story didn’t happen,
then really that should be labeled as fiction, and the author can make a side
note that some of the events in the plot were based off something that really
happened. This way the author isn’t being deceptive but can still let their
readers know about some things that occurred in their life.
But in
the end, though, it’s the author’s choice. If they want their readers to
believe a bunch of false facts that are labeled as true then fine, go ahead and
write them. All that matters is at the end they can be happy and proud of the
story that they’re telling to their audience who trustingly believe that it’s
true.
i agree with this whole post. i dont really care if the book isnt all true. but if most of it isnt, then that might make me mad that its a memoir instead of a fiction.
ReplyDeleteI personally think if it's a lie, and it's made up, whether the author wants the audience to know that or not, it should be fiction. People can't just lie. It's wrong.
ReplyDeleteI agree that if the book isn't true, it shouldn't be considered non-fiction. I also feel like I am being lied to when I am reading a book that is supposed to be true.
ReplyDeleteI agree that lying is wrong, but the dialouge can be slightly made up to get the point across if they can't remember.
ReplyDeleteP.S. I like the lightning in the background.
However, the problem comes when trying to determine the percentages. And how is the reader supposed to know what ten percent is the falsified information.
ReplyDelete