I think
schools should swap out some literary fiction for genre fiction. Not all
students like to read the books we read in school, so they just generalize that
feeling with all books. But since they’re limited to only one genre, how are
they supposed to know if they’d like other types of books or not? I know that
my sister hates to read. And the only time she reads is in school, where she’s
reading horribly boring books that she doesn’t care about. If schools taught
genre fiction, maybe she’d have the chance to realize she actually likes to
read, just not reading literary fiction.
Schools
should give us options. Maybe we could read two books a tri – one literary and
one genre fiction. And if they give us options for what we can read, then they
wouldn’t have to cut out any of the literary ones. They would still give us the
option to read it, but not everyone would pick to read each one. For example,
when it’s time to read the first book of the tri, we could be given the option
between Of Mice & Men and The Great Gatsby. Students will pick
which one sounds better to them, and then read it. This way they don’t feel as
forced to read something they don’t want to, since they were given an option. Also,
it wouldn’t completely replace Of Mice
& Men for Twilight. You are
still given the chance to hear about it and choose to read it. For the second
book that tri, you can be given the choice between, for example, The Hunger Games and Twilight. This, once again, gives
options for the kids who aren’t really a fan of the popular books and can pick
to not read the one that sounds completely horrid to them.
I would
love if schools could actually do this. I think it would expose the students to
more types of books other than literary fiction. But in order for the students
to actually enjoy this, and not just end up hating genre fiction, too, then notes and quizzes would have to be limited. Who
would want to take notes over Twilight any
ways? It ruins the fun of reading. I think an in-class worksheet or two would
be good enough. This way it once again takes away the thought of ‘I have to read this book’ since there
wouldn’t be a test over it, but still would be enough incentive for the student
to read at least some of the book in order to answer the questions on the
worksheet right.
Your idea makes sense to me, I just wish there was a better way to make sure people were reading without testing them and making them take notes. Again, great idea :).
ReplyDeleteI like this idea! That way most people would be happy with what they're reading.
ReplyDeleteI like your idea of letting kids pick which of the books they want to read, it would allow students to pick a book with a plot they might be interested in.
ReplyDelete